Charges against Vatican cardinal revive questions about Pope Francis’ handling of child sexual abuse by priests

ROME – A top Vatican official denied allegations of sexual offenses on Thursday after being charged by Australian police, saying he would take a leave of absence as one of Pope Francis’ chief advisers to defend himself.

Speaking to reporters in the Vatican, Cardinal George Pell denounced “relentless character assassination” in the media and confirmed he would return to his native Australia to face the charges. Australian police earlier Thursday announced that Pell faces multiple charges of “historical sexual assault offenses,” that nation’s term for charges related to past conduct.

Pell – Australia’s senior-most Catholic prelate – has for years faced questions in his role in the staggering scale of sexual abuse by the Australian church. But he has never before been directly charged. The controversy is a challenge to Pope Francis’ attempts to address the church’s long-running abuse scandal, particularly since much of the abuse in the Australian church was well-known at the time the pontiff appointed him to his current role.

“I repeat that I am innocent of these charges. They are false. The whole idea of sexual abuse is abhorrent to me,” the 76-year-old cardinal said.

The case pulls Francis’ papacy back into the abuse scandals that have battered the church for nearly two decades and led to demands for sweeping changes on monitoring, selecting and training the clergy. In the United States and elsewhere, groups continue to press for full accountability within the Catholic Church for alleged abuse of children and others going back generations.

Australian officials did not offer exact details about the alleged crimes, saying that Pell has a right to due process.

Last year, Australia’s state broadcaster interviewed two men who said Pell touched their genitals in the 1970s at a swimming pool in the cardinal’s home city of Ballarat. Pell has denied the allegations.

The Vatican, meanwhile, said it had learned of the charges “with regret” and that Francis appreciated the cardinal’s honesty and commitment during his three years working on reforming the Holy See’s finances.

Spokesman Greg Burke noted in the statement to reporters that Pell had in the past “repeatedly condemned as immoral and intolerable” acts of abuse against minors.

The cardinal has a key role overseeing Vatican finances, and is seen as the second-most powerful official in the Holy See after the pope.

The charges “will probably rock the Vatican like nothing else has ever done,” said Peter Saunders, a British abuse survivor who served on a papal commission investigating the abuse. “The fact that one of the pope’s right-hand men, the secretary for the economy, has in a sense been arrested and will be charged with such serious offenses, that surely has got to have some kind of effect on the Vatican and the hierarchy.”

Deputy Commissioner Shane Patton of Australia’s Victoria state announced Thursday that Pell had been summoned to face multiple charges of “historical sexual assault offense.”

He will appear before a Melbourne court on July 18.

Pell has been dogged for years by questions of whether he was aware of sexual abuse by priests. In 2016, he testified, via video, to an Australian court over abuse of minors in Ballarat, where he was a priest.

Pell, who entered the priesthood in 1966, was an adviser to the Bishop of Ballarat through the 1970s before becoming the archbishop of first Melbourne, and then Sydney. He was chosen to reform the church’s antiquated and opaque finances in 2014.

One victim of sexual abuse in Ballarat said Thursday that he did not feel any happiness at the charges against Pell, who was the episcopal vicar for education in the district in 1974, when the abuse against him took place.

“There is a commonality right around the world – it has been a global phenomena,” Peter Blenkiron, who was sexually abused at St. Patrick’s College in Ballarat. “We can’t let any one person take the spotlight from what needs to happen.”

Pell’s guilt or innocence is less important than the need to reform the church globally to prevent future sexual abuse, Blenkiron said.

“There are so many families that have lost a parent and brothers and sisters. It is so raw in Ballarat,” he said.

The allegations against Pell have split Australian society.

Former prime minister and prominent conservative Tony Abbott described the cardinal as a “very fine man indeed,” reflecting a view among some members of the Catholic establishment that Pell is being held responsible by elements of the media and left-wing activists for abuse in the broader church.

A recently published book, “The Cardinal,” written by a journalist who has pursued Pell for years, was withdrawn from sale in Australia on Thursday after the charges were filed because of the legal risk it could influence a future jury.

The charges are “extraordinarily significant, because George Pell is a lightning rod in Australia for those who are for or against the Catholic Church,” said the author, Louise Milligan.

The cardinal has faced several other allegations related to the Australian abuse situation, including that he sought to give financial aid to priests who had been jailed on pedophilia charges. The Italian journalist Emiliano Fittipaldi claimed this year he found documents tying Pell to the jailed priests.

Pell denied the charges.

“We’ll see how this papacy will try to cope, but this has been a deadly blow for the myth of Pope Francis’ reforms,” Fittipaldi said in an interview. “Francis has done some very important things, but the fight against pedophilia is not his priority.”

The Washington Post’s Birnbaum reported from Brussels and Patrick reported from Sydney. Paul Schemm in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, and Brian Murphy in Washington contributed to this report.

Local News

Anne McCudden steps down as History Center Director

Local News

Spring and March pointers in the landscape!

Local News

Pope’s Museum to debut new mural, exhibit on Saturday

Local News

Dan Bellamy wins 2nd Place Large Artistic Sculpture at International Twist & Shout competition

Local News

Reps. Taylor and Cannon enter final stretch of Legislative Session

Local News

Imagine Thomasville celebrates ribbon cutting for the Army Recruiting Station

Local News

First Commerce’s Barbara Williams-Anderson named Imagine Thomasville’s Woman of the Year

Local News

Two new bronze sculptures unveiled in Downtown Thomasville

Education

Valdosta State University announces Fall 2024 graduates

Education

The Warrior dedicated to Ramsey

Education

Dining for Education Scholarship event sets new record

Education

Thomasville City Schools introduces Bulldog +1 Program

Education

CHS named Region 1-AAA Literary Champions

Local News

City to host stormwater utility public information session

Local News

Thomasville Chapter DAR features program by Thomasville History Center Executive Director Anne McCudden

Local News

Incident Reports & Arrests 03-12

Local News

FLOST Referendum early voting wraps up this week

Education

Rotary Club helps fund CyberStingers’ trip to World Championship

Local News

City of Thomasville’s Family Movie Night returns to Ritz on March 15

Local News

Unlocking financial freedom: How to protect and grow your wealth in uncertain times

Local News

Reps. Cannon and Taylor help pass 75 bills on Crossover Day

Local News

Continue to enjoy portable plants in the landscape!

Education

SRTC names Amy Carter Davis Vice President for Economic Development

Education

Second Graders complete 10th Annual “Ikidarod” Relay