Housekeeper suspected in string of thefts

THOMASVILLE — A housekeeper who worked for several residents throughout Thomas County is now facing counts of theft after being turned in by a local business owner. 

On July 13, Nicole Montes, 34, was arrested for three counts of felony theft by taking, two counts of misdemeanor and theft by deception for stealing jewelry from her clients.

Authorities were notified by David Hufstetler, owner of American Pawn, who noticed Montes had pawned an unusual amount of jewelry within the past few months. 

Approximately $2,000 to $2,500 were obtained by Montes from 14-15 transactions made at the Cairo American Pawn and the Thomasville American Pawn. 

Hufstetler and law enforcement identified five of Montes’ clients who fell victim to her stealing.  

“Almost all of the jewelry with two or three exceptions had been tied to a victim and when I say victim, I mean the rightful owners,” Hufsteiler said. 

There were about 40 pieces of stolen jewelry recovered from the two pawn shops.

Capt. Tim Watkins, Thomas County Sheriff’s Office chief investigator, said there are still pieces of jewelry waiting to be claimed.

“There are several pieces of jewelry that have not been claimed by the owner. Not all jewelry has been reported,” he said. 

Hufsteiler said he hopes more victims reveal themselves as Montes’ crimes are uncovered. 

“Me and my employees live here too, and if this person will steal from those people, they’ll just soon steal from us,” he said, “and so we see it as part of our civic duty when we suspect there’s a crime to turn it in. Although we may lose that money, we see it as an investment in order to bring somebody to justice and hopefully get that person some help with whatever problem they need. We think it’s money well spent.”

Montes is currently at the Thomas County Jail and will be arraigned Wednesday afternoon at the Thomas County Magistrate Court.

Watkins said Montes can be sentenced to as much as 30 years in prison. 

Local News

Pursuit leads to fatal vehicle collision

Local News

Used needle found in contraband sweep

Education

Dylan Thompson named National Merit Finalist

Education

Thomasville City Schools enhances parent-teacher communication with new “Rooms” feature

Local News

More about adaptive gardening!

Local News

Meme Greitzer presents program to UDC

Local News

Thomasville Chapter DAR members attend Georgia State Society DAR State Conference

Local News

Reps. Taylor and Cannon welcome City of Thomasville to the Gold Dome

Local News

Thomas County Farm Bureau announces winner of bookmark contest

Local News

City of Thomasville to host annual spring clean events

Local News

Thomas County Farm Bureau’s Sumners serving on GFB YF&R Committee

Local News

Thomas County Public Works reports cost of litter control

Local News

Celebrate the human-canine bond at Tails & Trails 2025

Local News

Women veterans honored in new Pope’s Museum mural

Local News

Cairo Police Department investigating armed robbery

Local News

Students partake in the Great American Cleanup

Education

TCMS Band students shine in Universal Studios Sound Design Workshop

Local News

Thomasville Chapter DAR features program by Stephen Ferguson from Thomas University

Local News

A major adaptive gardening decision!

Local News

An Evening in the Garden raises funds for scholarships

Local News

Reps. Taylor and Cannon work to lower “tort tax”

Local News

Cassidy Rd. to see temporary lane closure

Local News

Georgia Foundation for Agriculture, Georgia Farm Bureau & Georgia EMC donate ag books to local libraries

Local News

Incident Reports & Arrests 03-24