Horses Roam Free on Georgia Island where the Carnegies Lived

Telling others during our travels that we are from Georgia often results in someone mentioning they experienced an enjoyable visit to Savannah, Jekyll Island or St. Simons Island. These are trendy Georgia tourist destinations and all three could easily be visited during a single trip along Georgia’s 100-mile Atlantic coastline.

When we mention our own favorite Georgia destination of Cumberland Island National Seashore, even experienced travelers generally offer a blank stare. Not only have they not visited the island, most have never heard of it. The unfamiliarity is their loss because the island is one of America’s true jewels.

At over 36,000 acres, Cumberland Island is Georgia’s largest and southernmost barrier island. Unlike the state’s heavily-developed barrier islands, Cumberland Island remains primarily in a natural state. Most of the land and surrounding marsh have been acquired by the U.S. Government for the establishment of Cumberland Island National Seashore, a unit of the National Park Service. Several private parcels of land remain, some of which will revert to the National Park Service at the deaths of the owners.

Cumberland Island has served as home to Native Americans, Spanish priests, British soldiers, and plantation owners. It is perhaps best known as a family estate of Thomas and Lucy Carnegie. Thomas was the younger sibling of the more famous Andrew Carnegie, steel magnate and philanthropist. In more recent years the island gained recognition as the location of John F. Kennedy, Jr.’s marriage to Carolyn Bessette.

The Carnegies acquired property on the island in the early 1880s and in 1884 began construction of their mansion, Dungeness, on the site of an earlier structure of the same name built by the widow of Revolutionary War hero Nathanael Greene. Greene had obtained a land grant from the U.S. Government.

Thomas Carnegie passed away in 1886, a year after completion of Dungeness, but his widow continued to live in the mansion and raise her nine children on the island. She built several additional homes for her married children whom she wished to remain on Cumberland Island.

Intertwining the island’s human history with its natural beauty – the peaceful marsh areas, beautiful live oak trees, and miles of stunning ocean beach – make Cumberland Island a special place visitors long remember.

We recently returned from our fourth visit to Cumberland Island and it was everything we remembered and more. The two of us split up, with one taking the day-long narrated van tour to the north end of the island, while the other spent the day on the island’s south end walking the trails, strolling the beach, and exploring the remains of Thomas and Lucy Carnegie’s Dungeness mansion.

Cumberland Island is accessible only via private boat or a National Park Service passenger ferry. The concessionaire-operated ferry offers service twice a day between the small village of St. Marys, Georgia, and the island. Tickets are sold at the nearby National Park Service visitor center. Reservations are recommended.

St. Marys is home to motels, several bed-and-breakfasts and an historic downtown hotel that remains in operation across from the boat dock. The hotel bar is worth a look. The town has an impressive waterfront park and several nearby restaurants.

The island has one historic bed-and-breakfast – the Greyfield Inn – but it is expensive, with rooms running up to $600 a night. Camping facilities are available for those who wish to tent. However, most visitors are day-trippers who depart on the early boat and return in the late afternoon. No food service is available on the island so visitors are advised to pack a lunch that includes a water bottle. Jill Hamilton-Anderson, National Park Service chief of interpretation, told us the park service tries to convey to visitors that they should arrive on the island self-sufficient for however long they plan to stay.

The majority of Cumberland Island’s 60,000 annual visitors, other than campers and guests of the B & B, spend about seven hours on the island. Our next column will explain why the national seashore deserves two full days, as we describe some of the island’s interesting experiences and sights.

David and Kay Scott are authors of “Complete Guide to the National Park Lodges” (Globe Pequot). Visit them at www.valdosta.edu/~dlscott/Scott

If you go

Getting there: The national seashore is accessible only by boat. A scheduled passenger ferry departs twice each morning from the village of St. Marys, Georgia, for the 45-minute voyage to the island. Reservations are advised, especially during the busy seasons of spring and fall. Most visitors take the earlier boat that departs St. Marys at 9 a.m. and return on the late boat that departs Cumberland Island at 4:45 p.m.

When to go: Spring and fall generally offer the best weather. Summers can be uncomfortably hot and winters can be cold. However, a reasonably warm day in November or early March is often ideal. Try to visit on a weekday when visitation is lighter.

Lodging: Greyfield Inn, one of the remaining Carnegie mansions operated as a bed-and-breakfast, is the island’s only lodging option. Guest rooms, some without a private bathroom, are in the $500 to $600 range, including meals and island tours. Motels and B & Bs in St. Marys are reasonable. St. Marys also has an historic downtown hotel across the street from the Cumberland Island ferry boat dock.

Camping: Cumberland Island has two developed campgrounds and three wilderness campgrounds. The maximum stay is seven consecutive days. The largest and easiest-to-access campground is Sea Camp, with 18 sites. It is a half mile from the Sea Camp Dock. Campers are responsible for transporting equipment from the dock to the campground.

What to take: Wear a long-sleeve shirt, long pants, and a hat to protect against sand gnats, mosquitos, and ticks. Take insect repellent and spray clothing as well as exposed skin. Visitors must bring their own food to the island. Drinking water is available at several locations on the southern portion of the island. Bring a water bottle.

Cost: Entrance to the seashore is $7 per adult. National park passes are accepted. Ferry roundtrips are $28 (adult), $26 (senior), and $18 (15 years and under). Personal bicycles are $10. Bicycle rentals on the island are $16. The Lands and Legacies Tour is $45 per person. Call (877) 860-6787 for reservations.

Local News

Modern vs. Contemporary furniture takes the stage at Center for the Arts

Local News

17th Century Colonial Dames hear program on Massachusetts Witch Trials

Lifestyles

Enrichment items complete the landscape!

Local News

Imagine Thomasville and Archbold Orthopedics celebrate grand opening and expanded healthcare services

Local News

Vita Fuse celebrates grand opening in Thomasville

News

Taylor and Cannon begin week one of Legislative Session 2025

Education

Thomas County Board of Education welcomes new leadership and member

Local News

TEF Concert Series continues Thursday with New York Polyphony

Local News

Sigma Gamma Rho Sorority, Inc. hosts successful coat drive

Local News

Incident Reports & Arrests 01-16

Education

SRTC Radiologic Technology students honored in pinning ceremony

Local News

Barwick city council to hold hearings on HB 581

Education

TCCHS Science Fair showcases student innovation

Local News

Flowers Auto Group donates $15,000—consecutively sponsoring Dinner on the Bricks for a decade

Local News

Spartan Wheel Chariots receives Honda donation

Local News

Covey Film Festival to premiere next Tuesday

Local News

Adult art classes and events to kick-off creative resolutions in 2025

Lifestyles

Green it or gray it in the landscape!

Local News

Cornerstone Collection expands at the History Center

Education

SRTC Foundation awards $79,500 in scholarships

Education

TCCHS musicians shine: 74 students earn seats in District Honor Band

Education

Thomasville City Schools to host Transition Fair 2025

Education

SRTC and UWA sign articulation agreement for Land, Forest, Wildlife Management Program

Local News

UDC chapter learns history about Secretary of State during WBTS era